Group usage from PyTango - TANGO Controls

# 7 years ago
gnyiri	hi, I am trying to use Group facility of Tango from python. The group command methods work fine but when I use get_device method for getting a DeviceProxy reference to a given Device some DeviceProxy methods fail (Exception: _green_mode). Note that the C++ version of the same scenario works as expected. Find both versions below: import PyTango if __name__ == "__main__": device_group = PyTango.Group("group") device_group.add("sys/tg_test/1") device_proxy_a = PyTango.DeviceProxy("sys/tg_test/1") device_proxy_b = device_group.get_device("sys/tg_test/1") try: print("direct access " + device_proxy_a.name() + " -> " + str(device_proxy_a.State()) + "\n") except Exception as e: print("Exception caught: " + str(e)) try: print("group access " + device_proxy_b.name() + " -> " + str(device_proxy_b.State()) + "\n") except Exception as e: print("Exception caught: " + str(e)) Output: direct access sys/tg_test/1 -> RUNNING Exception caught: _green_mode #include <tango.h> #include <log4tango.h> #include <vector> #include <unistd.h> int main(int argc,char argv[]) { Tango::Group l_group = new Tango::Group("group"); std::string l_device_name("sys/tg_test/1"); l_group->add(l_device_name); Tango::DeviceProxy* l_device_proxy_a = new Tango::DeviceProxy(l_device_name); Tango::DeviceProxy* l_device_proxy_b = l_group->get_device(l_device_name); try { std::cout << "direct access " << l_device_proxy_a->name() << " -> " << l_device_proxy_a->state() << std::endl; std::cout << "group access " << l_device_proxy_b->name() << " -> " << l_device_proxy_b->state() << std::endl; } catch(…) { std::cout << "Could not connect" << std::endl; } delete l_device_proxy_a; delete l_group; return 0; } Output: direct access sys/tg_test/1 -> 10 group access sys/tg_test/1 -> 10 I found some hints about green modes in PyTango documentation, but the concept is not clear to me in fact. Do you know why State() method throws an exception from Python (while it works properly in C++)? Thanks in advance, Gergely Nyiri Edited 7 years ago

# 7 years ago

hi,

I am trying to use Group facility of Tango from python. The group command methods work fine but when I use get_device method for getting a DeviceProxy reference to a given Device some DeviceProxy methods fail (Exception: _green_mode). Note that the C++ version of the same scenario works as expected. Find both versions below:


import PyTango


if __name__ == "__main__":
    device_group = PyTango.Group("group")
    device_group.add("sys/tg_test/1")

    device_proxy_a = PyTango.DeviceProxy("sys/tg_test/1")
    device_proxy_b = device_group.get_device("sys/tg_test/1")

    try:
        print("direct access " + device_proxy_a.name() + " -> " + str(device_proxy_a.State()) + "\n")
    except Exception as e:
        print("Exception caught: " + str(e))

    try:
        print("group access  " + device_proxy_b.name() + " -> " + str(device_proxy_b.State()) + "\n")
    except Exception as e:
        print("Exception caught: " + str(e))

Output:

direct access sys/tg_test/1 -> RUNNING

Exception caught: _green_mode


#include <tango.h>
#include <log4tango.h>
#include <vector>
#include <unistd.h>

int main(int argc,char *argv[])
{
  Tango::Group* l_group = new Tango::Group("group");
  std::string l_device_name("sys/tg_test/1");

  l_group->add(l_device_name);

  Tango::DeviceProxy* l_device_proxy_a = new Tango::DeviceProxy(l_device_name);
  Tango::DeviceProxy* l_device_proxy_b = l_group->get_device(l_device_name);

  try
  {
    std::cout << "direct access " << l_device_proxy_a->name() << " -> " << l_device_proxy_a->state() << std::endl;
    std::cout << "group access  " << l_device_proxy_b->name() << " -> " << l_device_proxy_b->state() << std::endl;
  }
  catch(…)
  {
    std::cout << "Could not connect" << std::endl;
  }

  delete l_device_proxy_a;
  delete l_group;

  return 0;
}

Output:

direct access sys/tg_test/1 -> 10
group access sys/tg_test/1 -> 10

I found some hints about green modes in PyTango documentation, but the concept is not clear to me in fact.

Do you know why State() method throws an exception from Python (while it works properly in C++)?

Thanks in advance,
Gergely Nyiri

Edited 7 years ago

# 7 years ago
Vincent M	Hi Gergely, It is a bug in PyTango. Could you report it here? Meanwhile, a quick fix could be: `device_proxy_b._green_mode = None` or better: `device_proxy_b.__init__(device_proxy_b)` Thanks for the report!

# 7 years ago

Vincent M

Hi Gergely,

It is a bug in PyTango. Could you report it here?

Meanwhile, a quick fix could be:

device_proxy_b._green_mode = None

or better:

device_proxy_b.__init__(device_proxy_b)

Thanks for the report!

# 7 years ago
gnyiri	hi Vincent, thanks for your quick reply. I have entered the issue as you suggested: https://github.com/tango-cs/PyTango/issues/21 Regards, Gergely

# 7 years ago
Vincent M	Thanks!